Feature;ECDIS;Traditional Radar;ARPA
<b>Geographic Context</b>;Detailed charts and surroundings;None;None
<b>Collision Avoidance</b>;AIS and radar overlays, route planning; Yes, but limited to visual radar returns; Automatic target tracking and course prediction
<b>Automatic Updates</b>;Yes (requires regular ENC updates);No;Yes (automatic vessel tracking)
<b>Range</b>;Global (via GPS and AIS);Short-range, line-of-sight;Short-range, focused on nearby vessels
<b>Primary Purpose</b>;Comprehensive navigation, route planning, safety;Obstacle detection, visual awareness;Collision avoidance, multi-target tracking
<b>Ease of Use</b>;Requires training, integrates multiple systems;Requires manual interpretation; Automatically tracks and predicts vessel movements
<b>Alarms</b>;Comprehensive: collision, route deviations, shallow water;Limited to proximity; Collision prediction alarms